Select Page
Happy cake.
You have now entered the cake-creation center. Here you’ll find cakes inspired by the people who order them, along with cakes to be inspired by, and for you to imagine. The Cakery was founded by the belief that cake isn’t mass-produced or made in a factory — it happens when an event is celebrated, and baked from scratch! 
Custom Cakes
Due to the level of heart and time I put into each cake, the cost of the custom edible art you receive is reflected. Most custom cakes, whether stacked, hand sculpted, or 3D can begin days, sometimes weeks in advance.   Each custom cake is priced based on the number of guests you would need to serve, the flavors chosen and the intricacy of the design aesthetic. 

Please keep in mind, since each custom cake is unique and is made/sculpted by hand – from cake – I highly recommend you reserve your date at least one month in advance to ensure availability. There are limited spaces available. A 50% non refundable deposit  will be due to reserve your date.  Once reserved,  it is yours alone, meaning I will not take in any new orders. Therefore there will be no refunds on any cancelled orders.

“Lisa can make an idea into a magical reality. It always turns out much better than I can ever dream of!”
Cupcakes are $2 each, or $25 a dozen with your choice of cake and a swirl of buttercream. Cupcakes with fillings are an additional $.50 per, or $36 a dozen. Minimal fondant decor begins at an additional 1$ per cupcake.

Cupcake bouquets are priced at 55$ – 65$ per arrangement, serving 15+ which includes cupcakes in either traditional or gourmet flavors and signature colors, a reusable glass vase, and a personalized card.

Wedding Cakes
The starting price point for a traditional buttercream only cake is $4.50 per serving and can go up to $15 per serving depending on the intricacies of the design, this does not include florals or greenery. The ever popular naked or semi naked cakes begin at 4$ per serving without any additional adornments.

All wedding and groomsmen cakes are either frosted with The Cakery’s traditional buttercream or a chocolate ganache. All fresh flowers requested for cakes must be ordered and paid prior to your scheduled date, however The Cakery will gladly pick up to adorn your cake a day prior to delivery.

The Cakery offers tastings for $40. This includes your choice of three cake flavors, fillings, and frostings. Three mini two-layer custom cakes will then be created and delivered directly to you, therefore you can taste at your leisure.  Simply call or email to arrange further consultation, after you have sampled, to discuss the details.  

Smash Cakes
These 5” buttercream cakes with minimal design range from $25-$50, and can be personalized. More detailed, 7” piped buttercream Unicorn Cakes include a fondant horn, ears and eyes, which can be personalized and are priced at $85 each. More intricate, fondant-covered unicorns begin at $100. 
Specialty Cakes 

All 3 layers fresh, baked from scratch
6″ serving 12+ | 45$
7″ serving 18+ | 55$
8″ serving 28+ | 65$
10″ serving 42+ | 75$
12″ serving 52+ | 85$

The Bugsy | Carrot Cake + whipped cream cheese frosting 

The Genevieve  | Chocolate Cake + raspberry filling + dark chocolate ganache + vanilla

Vanilla Raspberry  | Vanilla Cake + raspberry filling + vanilla bean buttercream

Strawberry Shortcake | Vanilla Cake + strawberries + vanilla bean buttercream 

The Dark Cookie | Chocolate cake + oreo cookies and cream buttercream + crushed oreos

Coconut Cream | Coconut cream cake + vanilla buttercream + toasted coconut

Cinnamon Roll | Cinnamon Swirl Vanilla Cake + vanilla

All American | Vanilla cake + homemade fresh apple pie filling + vanilla buttercream 

Lemon  Drop | Lemon cream cake + homemade and fresh lemon filling + vanilla buttercream 

The Turtle | Chocolate cake + salted caramel buttercream + whipped chocolate mousse + toffee bits

The German Schmear | Chocolate cake + toasted pecan and coconut frosting + chocolate ganache + candied pecans

The Jacob  | Banana cake + chocolate mousse + salted caramel buttercream

Shawnee’s Cake | Chocolate cake + fresh black cherry compote + whipped vanilla buttercream

The Joey Michaelangelo  | Angel food cake +  fresh fruit + homemade whipped cream

Say Hello!

By Appointment Only:

104 C West 14th Street, Elmira Heights, NY 14903


© 2022 The Cakery, All Rights Reserved